How to Appeal When Your Medical Insurance Declines Your Claim

(Last Updated On: September 28, 2022)

In recent years, medical insurance companies refusing claims to save money has caused concern. These insurance companies have been criticized for putting their bottom line ahead of their customers’ health. This has led to many people being unable to afford the care they need.

Your insurance claim may have been turned down because the company was trying to save money. They may have turned down your claim because they didn’t think it was necessary or because they thought it would cost too much. Before you file a new claim, ask your doctor for a second opinion. 

Don’t give up if you’re denied. You could lodge an appeal. 

Find out why your claim was denied. You should receive a letter from your insurance provider explaining why coverage was denied to you. Once you have discovered the reason, you can begin collecting evidence to support your appeal. 

For example, if your claim was refused because your insurance company believed the treatment was not medically necessary, you can ask your doctor to submit a letter outlining why the therapy is required. You are free to provide evidence supporting your claim if it was rejected because you did not fulfill the pre-authorization requirements. 

Most claims are denied for different reasons. The absence of required data is probably the factor that will cause your health insurance provider to reject your claim. Check that all pre-authorization requests have been filled out correctly with the appropriate patient information before appealing a claim that has been denied. 

Is your social security number, for example, appropriately listed? Does the doctor possess the most recent copy of your health plan’s identity card? Is your doctor using the most recent copy of diagnostic and treatment codes to fill out the papers correctly?

You are ready to go to the next step after confirming that you have provided good documentation to the physician and that the physician has submitted good evidence to the health plan. Think paranoid when interacting with your health insurance company.

Record every phone call, contact person, and item of information you receive. It just takes one communication breakdown to cause a problem; you are preparing for any appeals case by documenting your interactions with the insurance provider.

If you’re appealing treatment coverage, make sure you’ve read your company’s health insurance handbook. Most patients fail to read the handbooks provided by their insurance carrier. These handbooks outline plan requirements and appeal processes, and you should make sure that your plan covers any therapy you intend to have before receiving it, if feasible.

Reasons Why Medical Insurance May Decline Your Claim

Here are some common causes for a refused medical insurance claim: 

1. Your doctor didn’t submit the correct paperwork. One of the most common reasons claims are dismissed is that the doctor didn’t submit the necessary paperwork. This could be because they forgot to include something or submitted the wrong form. In this case, speak with your doctor and request that they update the papers with the relevant details. 

2. You didn’t meet your deductible. You usually have to meet your deductible first to approve your claims. If you don’t meet your deductible, the insurance company won’t pay for it.

3. You met your deductible but not your co-pay. Some medical insurance plans have co-pays that need to be met before they will pay for a service or treatment. If you didn’t meet your co-pay, the insurance company won’t pay for it.

4. You have a plan that doesn’t cover mental health. Some plans only cover medical treatments that are considered to be “medically necessary.” Mental health treatments and medications are not always considered to be medically necessary.

5. You have a plan that doesn’t cover pre-existing conditions. Many medical plans don’t cover pre-existing medical conditions for 6 months or a year after you start your plan. Your pre-existing mental health condition may not be covered for the first six months or year of your new health insurance plan. 

6. You want your mental health care paid for all year. Many medical plans only cover mental health care for the first 6 months or a year.

7. Your insurance company won’t pay for your treatments. They won’t pay for it if you don’t get prior approval from your insurance company.

8. You want to see a psychiatrist instead of a psychologist. Many medical plans will only pay for the services of a psychologist, not a psychiatrist.

9. You want to see a therapist. Many medical plans only pay for the services of a psychologist, not a therapist.

10. You want to see a counselor. Many medical plans only pay for the services of a psychologist, not a counselor.

11. You want to see a nurse practitioner or physician’s assistant (PA). Many medical plans don’t allow you to see these people.

12. You want to see a specialist. Many medical plans don’t allow you to see specialists.

13. You want to see a non-network provider. Many medical plans only pay for the services of providers who are part of their network.

14. You have a problem with your insurance, e.g., the premium went up, your plan was canceled, etc. 

What Are The Grounds For An Appeal? 

A claim can be denied for several reasons. Your plan does not include coverage for the service you are asking for is by far the most typical explanation. You can urge the insurer to reconsider. You can be asked to give further evidence regarding why the service is medically necessary.

You may also appeal the judgment if the insurance company rejects your claim because you did not comply with the coverage standards. For example, if you have to get prior approval for a procedure and you didn’t do so, you can appeal and explain why the procedure was necessary. You may also be able to appeal if the insurance company says there was a mistake in processing your claim.

You have the right to request that the insurance provider reevaluate their decision if you think a service ought to be covered. For example, if they accidentally applied a deductible to a service that shouldn’t have had one. You can also appeal if the insurance company says they won’t cover a service because it’s experimental or investigational.

You may present more information about why the service is covered. The insurance company may ask the plan administrator to review the decision. The plan administrator is responsible for deciding what services are covered and whether they’re experimental or investigational. You can also appeal if you have an unusual circumstance that caused your injury, illness, or disability.

For example, if you were injured because of a crime. Or if you have a condition that’s not well known or for which there aren’t suitable treatments. If you’re in a group health plan and get your health care from a provider that’s not in the plan, you’ll need to appeal to your insurance company. They may have their own procedures for appealing. Check with them or with the plan administrator.

When an Appeal Is Required

You should follow the appeals procedure explicitly because every plan should have one. You should consult with your doctor before appealing the claim so that they may give any necessary supporting paperwork and expertise. Remember that most insurance claims must be appealed within a specific time frame, so if you wait six weeks after a refusal and only have 60 days to appeal, you may be out of luck.

Before resorting to an external source, such as a federal or state appeals process, you should always appeal internally to your insurance provider. Most appeals follow the following procedure:

  • Phone Complaint
  • Written Complaint
  • Written Appeal

Again, be precise about your plan’s coverage rules and record all communications with the insurance carrier. While most legal appeals are allowed by the insurance carrier, there are documented cases of insurance fraud and health plans that don’t follow the criteria. Patients can exhaust their options against the insurance carrier for a valid appeal and then take it to the next level by documenting response times and any mandatory response periods.

Many states have laws that govern an appeal to a state or federal insurance supervision procedure; these laws frequently allow for an external, professional examination of the appeal. A board of trained professionals can then judge your case on an individual basis if you provide correct documentation and detailed medical backing from your physical. Your insurance company will be unable to deny the claim if an external appeal validates it and overturns the refusal.

Knowledge of your health plan, your doctor’s knowledge of procedures, and a thorough review of the appeals process are your best tools for obtaining the therapy you require. Do not overlook the details; preserve proper paperwork and review your coverage plans if you have any questions. Remember that there are always alternatives. 

How to Craft a Compelling Case 

Here’s how to craft a compelling case that will improve your chances of getting the coverage you need and deserve.

Start by requesting a written explanation of the denial from your health insurance company. This notice should explain why your claim was denied and what you can do to appeal the decision.

Next, gather any additional documentation that may help support your case. This could include medical records, bills, and letters from your doctor.

Now it’s time to put together your appeal letter. Be sure to include all relevant information, such as your policy number, claim number, and the dates of service in question. Clearly state why you believe the denial was incorrect and provide any supporting evidence you have gathered.

Send your appeal letter to your health insurance company and make a copy for yourself. Keep track of any correspondence with the company and send copies to your doctor or medical provider if they are helping you appeal the decision. After you have submitted your appeal, do not expect a quick response.

How To Document Your Medical Condition For Insurance AppealsĀ 

If your medical insurance claim is denied, you have the right to appeal the decision. To have a successful appeal, you must document your medical condition and treatment clearly and concisely. Here are some tips on how to document your medical condition for an insurance appeal:

1. Keep a detailed record of all your medical appointments, treatments, and tests. Include dates, times, and descriptions of what occurred at each appointment.

2. Keep track of all costs associated with your medical care, including co-pays, prescriptions, and mileage.

3. Gather any supporting documentation from your health care providers, such as lab results or x-rays.

4. Describe your medical condition and how it’s affected you. If you have ever had a medical insurance claim denied, you know the feeling of frustration and helplessness that can come with it. 

How To Write An Appeal Letter

By following these steps, you can write an effective appeal letter and give yourself a better chance of having your claim approved.

1. Read the notice carefully and make sure you understand the reason for the denial.

2. Write a clear and concise letter explaining why you believe the denial is incorrect. Include supporting evidence. 

3. Address your letter to the appropriate person or department listed on the denial notice.

4. Send your letter by certified mail so that you have proof of delivery.

5. Be patient. It can take weeks to resolve appeals and sometimes longer. If your appeal is denied again by the same person or department, consider filing a complaint with your state insurance department. 


If your medical insurance declines your claim, you can do a few things to appeal the decision. First, make sure that you have all of the documentation that is needed to appeal the decision. This includes any medical records or bills that you have. Next, write a letter to your insurance company explaining why you believe that they should cover your claim. Finally, be persistent and follow up with your insurance company until you get a response.


Leave a Reply